Following a playful photo session with her mother and the submission of the results to a local modeling agency, Everhart was on a plane to Paris later that year. By the end of the following year, she had graced the covers of such fashion mainstays as ELLE and Glamour magazine (for which she was the first-ever red-haired cover girl). Though a riding accident in which she broke her back at the age of 19 nearly put an end to her aspirations, Everhart eventually recovered through physical therapy. Early in her career, Everhart was advised she would never be a top model because she was a redhead. However, she succeeded in her chosen career and posed for numerous publications. She appeared in several issues of the annual Sports Illustrated swimsuit edition, starting in 1995. After years of publicly insisting she would never pose nude, Everhart did just that for the February 2000 issue of Playboy. She was ranked #98 on the FHM 100 Sexiest Women of 2003.

Everhart made her film debut in 1993 with the Arnold Schwarzenegger action-comedy Last Action Hero. She has since appeared in such features as Tales From the Crypt Presents: Bordello of Blood (1996), Denial (1998), Trigger Happy (1996) and Gunblast Vodka (2000). Other movies she has appeared in include Jade (1995), and Executive Target (1997), Since then, her feature film roles have been restricted to low budget erotic thrillers with obligatory nude scenes, such as Another 9 1/2 Weeks (1997) Sexual Predator (2001) and Bare Witness (2001).

She has also appeared on reality television. In 2004, she appeared in Celebrity Mole: Yucatan, in which she was the rogue agent sabotaging the group. She was one of the "Gingers" on the second season of The Real Gilligan's Island (the other was Erika Eleniak), but left the show when she accidentally cut her finger severely enough to sever tendons and require surgery. Angie was also a panelist on To Tell The Truth from 2000 to 2001. Everhart was a co-host on the ABC reality show The Ex-Wives Club, along with Marla Maples, and Shar Jackson in 2007. She is signed to London modeling agency Models 1, and New York Model Management.

• Mafioso II (2009) (pre-production) .... Agent Jill Moran
  
• The Unknown Trilogy (2008) (V) .... Donna Patullo
• Bigfoot (2008) .... Brooke Caldwell
• Gone (2007/II) .... Donna Patulo
• "The Dr. Keith Ablow Show" (1 episode, 2006)
       - Painful Celebrity Breakups (2006) TV episode
• Cloud 9 (2006) .... Julie
• Payback (2006)
• Coming Attractions (2006) .... Supermodel
• Bandido (2004) .... Natalie
• The Cradle Will Fall (2004) (TV) .... Katie DeMaio
  ... aka Mary Higgins Clark's The Cradle Will Fall (UK: complete title)
• The Hollywood Mom's Mystery (2004) (TV) .... Julia Prentice
• Bugs (2003) (TV) .... Emily Foster
• 1st to Die (2003) (TV) .... Chessy Jenks
  ... aka F1rst to Die (USA: promotional title)
  ... aka James Patterson's F1rst to Die (USA: promotional title)
• The Real Deal (2002) .... Samantha Vassar
• "UC: Undercover" .... Carly (5 episodes, 2001-2002)
       - The Sins of Sonny Walker (2002) TV episode .... Carly
       - Nobody Rides for Free (2001) TV episode .... Carly
       - Honor Among Thieves (2001) TV episode .... Carly
       - Amerikaz Most Wanted (2001) TV episode .... Carly
       - Kiss Tomorrow Goodbye (2001) TV episode .... Carly
• Bare Witness (2002) (V) .... Carly Marsh
• Wicked Minds (2002) (TV) .... Lana
  ... aka Esprits tordus (Canada: French title)
• Last Cry (2001) (V) .... Beth Spinella
  ... aka Dangerous Desires (USA: cable TV title)
  ... aka Sexual Predator (Australia: video title)
• The Substitute: Failure Is Not an Option (2001) (V) .... Jenny
• Point Doom (2001) .... Jessica
• Heart of Stone (2001) .... Mary Sanders
• Gunblast Vodka (2000) .... Jane Woods
• "Law & Order: Special Victims Unit" .... Emily Waterbury (1 episode, 2000)
  ... aka Law & Order: SVU (USA: promotional abbreviation)
  ... aka Special Victims Unit (New Zealand: English title)
       - Disrobed (2000) TV episode .... Emily Waterbury
• The Stray (2000) .... Kate Grayson